
Zoggs Aqua Plugz
- Ergonomically shaped
- Reusable · carry case included
- Work loose in the water
- Fit depends heavily on ear shape
Twenty pairs, ten weeks in the pool and the sea, and one that actually stayed put and kept the water out. Here’s the shortlist, and why the top pick wins.
See our #1 pick ›
The only pair in our test that sealed reliably and stayed put through tumble turns and open-water swells — and the one we’d actually keep in the swim bag.
✓ Free UK / EU shipping today · 40-day money-back
Public-health advice for swimmers comes down to one thing: keep your ears dry. The NHS advice is to use earplugs or a swimming hat over your ears when you swim.
So the only thing that makes a swimming plug worth having is whether it actually seals and stays put. Nearly every cheap plug we tested sealed fine standing at the poolside, then worked loose the moment we pushed off. We scored on four things: whether it keeps water out, whether it stays in through a real swim, whether it is still comfortable at the end of one, and whether it fits a range of ear sizes. A plug that only helps if it seals is a plug you have to get right, which is why fit matters more than the price on the box.
Most budget plugs are one moulded shape in one size, so they only seal well if your ear canal happens to match. A tumble turn, a dive, or an open-water swell then breaks that seal and the plug drifts.
The winner uses a soft two-lamella design: two flexible flanges that flex to the canal and hold against pressure changes. It is the reason it kept the water out when the fixed-shape plugs let it back in.
One pair kept the water out from the first length to the last.
See our #1 pick ›Across ten weeks of pool lengths and cold open-water swims, BOLLSEN Watersafe+ was the only pair that stayed sealed and in place from the first length to the last.
Every fixed-shape plug we tested let water back in after a tumble turn. The two-lamella seal was the one that didn’t.
Watersafe+ held its seal below the surface, not just against splashing. Testers reported dry ears after full sessions, including dives and duck-unders where thinner plugs flushed through.
The soft two-lamella flanges flex to the ear canal and grip through movement. Where budget plugs drifted on the push-off, these held through tumble turns, sprint sets and open-water swells.
The medical-grade silicone drew no complaints over long swims — no pressure, no ache. They rinse clean and are reusable up to 100 times, so one pair lasted our daily swimmers a full season, backed by a 40-day money-back guarantee.
This is where most of the field came unstuck. Zoggs depends heavily on ear shape, Mack’s ran too large for most ears, and Alpine runs small enough to rule out larger canals. Two flexible flanges adapt to the canal instead of relying on it matching one moulded shape, which is the whole reason the seal held where the fixed-shape plugs drifted.
The one pair we’d actually keep in the swim bag — with 40 days to change your mind.
See our #1 pick ›



The only pair of the five that held its seal from the first length to the last, through tumble turns, dives and open-water swells.
| Scored on | Watersafe+ | Zoggs | Speedo | Mack’s | Alpine |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keeps water out | ✓ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ✗ |
| Stays in through a swim | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ~ |
| Comfortable on a long swim | ✓ | ~ | ~ | ✗ | ~ |
| Fits a range of ear sizes | ✓ | ✗ | ~ | ✗ | ✗ |
✓ met · ~ mixed · ✗ missed — scored on the pros and cons inside each card above; tap a card to open it.
See our #1 pick ›Every pair was bought at full retail. Testers scored each on four things: whether it held a seal below the surface, whether it stayed in through tumble turns, dives and open-water swells, whether it stayed comfortable over a long swim, and whether it fitted a range of ear sizes. Nothing here was supplied by a manufacturer.
TrustScore comparison · 7 September 2026
Trustpilot gives every company it lists a TrustScore out of 5 and a rating band. We looked up the branded reusable earplugs that appear in our tests. Only one of them reaches the top band, Excellent.
| Rank | Brand | TrustScore |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | BOLLSEN Hearing Protection | 4.3Excellent |
| 2 | Alpine Hearing Protection | 4.1Great |
| 3 | Flare Audio | 4.0Great |
| 4 | Loop Earplugs | 3.6Average |
Excellent starts at 4.3 on Trustpilot. A perfect 5.0 usually means a company has collected very few ratings, so one more review moves the score. BOLLSEN is the only brand here that reaches it, on a profile you can open and check yourself.
Method. TrustScores read from each brand’s public Trustpilot profile on 7 September 2026. Where a brand runs several country profiles, we used the one with the most reviews, so every row shows a global profile rather than a local one. Brands with fewer than 250 reviews are not shown. Star ratings are the ones Trustpilot displays, rounded to the nearest half star. Trustpilot bands: Excellent 4.3 to 5.0, Great 3.8 to 4.2, Average 3.0 to 3.7. Scores change as new reviews come in. Compiled independently by UK Consumer Review Company. Not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by Trustpilot.
Stan J.★★★★★Verified buyer · United Kingdom
“I used the Bollsen ear plugs for my 1 hour swim and they worked great. Never had to adjust them or worry about them falling out.”
Jane S.★★★★★Verified buyer · United Kingdom
“Had tried a variety of shapes and sizes of earplugs but they either didn’t fit or were uncomfortable. I was wary when I bought my first set of Watersafe+ but am so happy with the comfort and fit that I have bought more. Brilliant!”
Kerry P.★★★★☆Verified buyer · United Kingdom
“These are flexible, well-designed earplugs, and certainly keep the water out of my ears during swimming. I do think they’re overpriced, though. The metal case is unnecessary and rather cumbersome […].”
Customer reviews from BOLLSEN stores.
That was the whole test. Most budget plugs are a single moulded shape, so they seal at the poolside and then work loose the moment you push off. Watersafe+ uses two flexible flanges that adapt to the canal and hold when the pressure changes. It was the only pair of the five that stayed sealed from the first length to the last. Duck-unders and dives are inside what it is built for.
Swimmer’s ear is irritation of the ear canal that can follow water sitting in there after a swim. Usually it shows up as itching, an ache, or a blocked feeling. The general advice for anyone prone to it is to keep the ears dry, which is what these are for: they hold a seal through a swim, so less water gets in to sit there. An earplug is not a treatment, though. If you have ear pain, discharge or any change in hearing, see a GP or pharmacist rather than working around it.
That was our first reaction too. Three of the four cheaper pairs worked loose in the water, which makes them money you spend again next season. Watersafe+ is rated for up to 100 uses. Swim three times a week and that works out at roughly 30p a session across a year.
Almost every budget plug is one shape in one size, so it only seals if your ear canal happens to match. These are soft medical-grade silicone with a two-lamella flange that adapts to the canal instead. They also ship in a metal case rather than a plastic bag, which is a fair part of why our testers still had theirs at the end of the season.
Yes. They cut noise, rated SNR 24 dB measured dry, but they do not seal you off. In the water their job is keeping water out rather than making things silent. Anyone calling you from the poolside is still loud enough to hear.
There is a 40-day money-back guarantee, so you can judge the fit in the water rather than in a shop. Fit is the whole game with a swimming plug. A pair that only works when it seals is a pair you have to get right.
Rinse them in fresh water after a swim, wash them occasionally with mild soap, and put them back in the case. They are rated to 100 uses. The case is usually what decides whether you still own them in September.